Initiating & Building Trust in Peer Relationships

Lesson: Building Effective Peer Relationships
Time Estimate: ~10 minutes

• Reading Time: ~6 minutes (1,050 words / 175 wpm)
• Activity: Interactive case study (5-7 minutes)

📖 Learning Objectives

By the end of this topic, you will be able to:
✅ Understand why trust is the foundation of peer relationships
✅ Identify key behaviors that build trust and those that break it
✅ Use nonjudgmental engagement to create a safe, welcoming space

🔍 Why Trust Matters in Peer Support

Trust is the cornerstone of effective peer support. Without it, peers may feel hesitant to open up, engage, or accept support. Many individuals have experienced stigma, judgment, or broken trust in past support systems—our role as peer specialists is to create a space where they feel safe, heard, and respected.

🗣️ “People don’t care how much you know until they know how much you care.”

Building trust doesn’t happen instantly—it’s developed over time through consistent, supportive, and nonjudgmental interactions. Let’s explore what builds trust and what can break it.

✅ What Builds Trust in Peer Relationships

Trust is built through reliable, compassionate, and respectful interactions. The following key behaviors help establish and maintain trust with peers:

✔ Consistency & Reliability – Show up when you say you will, follow through on commitments
✔ Nonjudgmental Attitude – Accept peers as they are, without criticism or pressure
✔ Active Listening – Be fully present, engaged, and attentive in conversations
✔ Respect for Boundaries – Maintain ethical and professional relationships
✔ Empathy & Understanding – Validate experiences and offer emotional support
✔ Confidentiality & Safety – Respect privacy and only share when necessary for safety

✅ Example: A peer shares that they’ve relapsed. Instead of reacting with disappointment, a trust-building response would be:

“I appreciate you sharing that with me. What do you think would help you move forward?”

This reinforces trust by providing support, not judgment.

🚫 What Breaks Trust in Peer Relationships

While trust takes time to build, it can be damaged quickly if peer specialists engage in behaviors that make peers feel judged, unsafe, or unheard.

🚫 Common Trust-Breaking Behaviors:
❌ Inconsistency – Canceling meetings, failing to follow through on commitments
❌ Giving Unsolicited Advice – Telling peers what to do instead of empowering their choices
❌ Minimizing or Invalidating Feelings – Saying things like, “You’ll get over it” or “It’s not that bad”
❌ Over-Sharing Personal Experiences – Making conversations about yourself rather than the peer
❌ Breaking Confidentiality – Sharing personal information without consent

Example: If a peer confides in you about struggling with depression and you respond with “You just need to stay positive”, this can shut down trust and make them feel unheard.

✅ Instead, try: “That sounds really difficult. I’m here to listen—do you want to talk more about it?”

🛠 Strategies for Initiating Trust

When meeting a peer for the first time, it’s important to create a safe, welcoming environment where they feel comfortable opening up. Here are key strategies for initiating trust from the start:

🔹 Meet Peers Where They Are – Accept them as they are, without expectations
🔹 Use Open-Ended Questions – Encourage conversation and self-reflection
🔹 Let Them Lead – Avoid dominating conversations—listen more than you speak
🔹 Honor Their Perspective – Acknowledge their experiences as valid and important
🔹 Share When It’s Helpful – Use your lived experience selectively, only when it benefits the peer

✅ Example: Instead of asking “Why haven’t you gone to meetings?”, ask “What kind of support has felt most helpful for you in the past?” This allows the peer to explore their own recovery journey rather than feel defensive.

🗣️ “Trust starts when peers feel seen, heard, and respected for who they are.”

📌 Key Takeaways

✔ Trust is the foundation of all peer relationships—it must be built with care and intention.
✔ Consistency, empathy, and respect create a safe and welcoming environment.
✔ Breaking trust happens quickly when peers feel judged, invalidated, or unsafe.
✔ Trust is built through listening, reliability, and honoring a peer’s unique journey.

📌 Click Next to Continue to the Next Topic!

📚 References & Research

📖 SAMHSA’s Core Competencies for Peer Workers in Behavioral Health (SAMHSA.gov)
📖 National Association of Peer Supporters (NAPS) Best Practices in Peer Relationships (NAPS.org)
📖 Trauma-Informed Approaches to Building Trust in Peer Support – National Center for Trauma-Informed Care